For the last thirty years, psychiatrists have been
familiar with the image of Benjamin Rush, peering at them from the
APA's logo, which first appeared in the American Journal of Psychiatry
in 1967. Known as the 'Father of American Psychiatry,' Rush
was, of course, not a psychiatrist, that is, a specialist in treating the
mentally ill, as such specialization didnot exist during his lifetime (1746-1813).
Just how he became psychiatry’s father is unclear though probably explained
bythe fact that he was a signer of the Declaration of Independence and
author of the first and for many years the onlyAmerican treatise on mental
illness, Medical Inquires and Observations upon the Diseases of the
Mind, published in 1812 .
During his lifetime Rush was probably
better known for his work on behalf of temperance. He wrote one of the
earliest medical works on alcoholism, An Inquiry Into the Effects of Ardent
Spirits Upon the body and Mind, published in 1785. This tract represented
a radical challenge to previous thinking that the consumption of
alcohol was a positive good. Rush was the first American to call chronic
drunkenness a distinct disease.
Rush also has acquired a reputation
as a psychiatric reformer. This is largely based on what is known
of his work at the Pennsylvania
Hospital. This hospital was the first general hospital in the
colonies and the first hospital in the colonies to treat insanity. Initially
'lunaticks' were housed in cold damp cells in the basement of the hospital,
a practice rationalized by the common eighteenth century view that,
since the mad had lost their reason, they were little more than beasts.
Evidence exists that Rush did petition the managers of the hospital to
provide more comfortable accommodations in a separate wing of the
hospital. While Rush is often given credit for this “reform,” one historian
has suggested that the requests of wealthy families for more
spacious private rooms for their relatives was probably responsible for
the implementation of his proposal.
Those honoring Rush as psychiatry’s father
have struggled most with the fact that his treatment methods seem
barbaric. No mere empiricist, however, Rush derived the rationale for
these treatments from his theory that illness was caused by
disordered blood flow. Rush adopted the use of a device known as the
'gyrater,' which spun the patient around on a board to increase the pulse.
He was quite proud of his invention of the 'Tranquilizer,'
a chair that he boasted “binds and confines every part of the body”
and “acts as a sedative to the tongue and temper as well as to the blood
vessels.” In addition, for recent or violent cases, Rush devised
a regimen of bleeding, purging and blistering that quickly reduced the
patient to a weakened and therefore more manageable state.
Founders of the APA, like Isaac Ray, defined
their “moral treatment,” in part by contrast to Rush’s 'heroic
treatment.' While Rush is usually given the entire credit (or
blame, depending on the scholar’s politics) for developments at the Pennsylvania
Hospital and his treatment methods, Rush’s work is best seen, as the historian
Nancy Tomes has noted, as part of a broader consensus about the proper
treatment of the insane that emerged in that period.