Miss A., æt. 17, under the care of Mr. Kelson Wright, of the Clapham Road, was brought to me on Jan.. 17, 1866. Her emaciation was very great. It was stated that she had lost 33 lbs. in weight. She was the 5 st. 12 lbs. Height, 5ft. 5in. Amenorrhœa for nearly a year. No cough. respirations throughout chest everywhere normal. Heart-sounds normal. Resps. 12; pulse, 56. no vomiting nor diarrhœa. Slight constipation. Complete anorexia for animal food, and almost complete anorexia for everything else. Abdomen shrunk and flat, collapsed. No abnormal pulsations of aorta. tongue clean. Urine normal. Slight deposits of phosphates on boiling. The condition was one of simple starvation. There was but slight variation in her condition, though observed at intervals of three or four months. The pulse was noted on these several occasions as 56 and 60. Resps. 12 to 15. The urine was always normal, but varied in sp. gr., and was sometimes as low as 1005. The case was regarded as one of simple anorexia. …Occasionally for a day or two the appetitie was voracious, but this was very rare and exceptional. The patient complained of no pain, but was restless and active. This was in fact a striking expression of the nervous state, for it seemed hardly possible that a body so wasted could undergo the exercise which seemed agreeable. There was some peevishness of temper, and a feeling of jealousy. No account could be given of the exciting cause.
Sir William Withey Gull MD Bart, "Anorexia nervosa (apepsia hysterica, anorexia hysterica)," Transactions of the Clinical Society of London, 7, 22-8
What
treatment was prescribed?
Various remedies were prescribed--the preparations
of cinchona, the bichloride of mercury, syrup of the iodide of iron, syrup
of the phosphate of iron, citrate of quinine and iron, &c.--but no
perceptible effect followed their administration. The diet also was varied,
but without any effect on the appetite.
Miss A remained under my observation from Jan. 1866
to March 1868, when she had much improved, and gained in weight from 82
to 128 lbs. The improvement from this time continued, and I saw no more
of her medically. The
Woodcut, Miss A., No. 2, from photograph taken in 1870, shows her condition
at that time. It will be noticeable that as she recovered she had a much
younger look, corresponding indeed to her age, 21; whilst the photographs,
taken when she was 17, give her the appearance of being near 30. Her health
has continued good…
How did
Gull understand this case?
It will be observed that all the conditions in this
case were negative, and may be explained by the anorexia which led to starvation,
and a depression of all the vital functions; viz., amenorrhœa, slow pulse,
slow breathing. In the stage of greatest emaciation one might have been
pardoned for assuming that there was some organic lesion, but from the
point of view indicated such an assumption would have been unnecessary.…The
want of appetite is I believe, due to a morbid mental state. I have not
observed in these cases any gastric disorder to which the want of appetite
could be referred. I believe, therefore, that its origin is central and
not peripheral. That mental states may destroy appetite is notorious, and
it will be admitted that young women at the ages named are specially obnoxious
to mental perversity. We might call the state hysterical without committing
ourselves to the etymological value of the word, or maintaining that the
subjects of it have the common symptoms of hysteria. i prefer, however,
the more general term of 'nervosa,' since the disease occurs in males as
well as females, and is probably rather central than peripheral. The importance
of discriminating such cases in practice is obvious; otherwise prognosis
will be erroneous, and treatment misdirected.
In one of the cases i have named the patient had
been sent abroad for one or two winters, under the idea that there was
a tubercular tendency. I have remarked …that these wilful patients are
often allowed to drift their own way into a state of extreme exhaustion,
when it might have been prevented by placing them under different moral
conditions.
The treatment required is obviously that which is
fitted for persons of unsound mind. The patients should be fed at regular
intervals, and surrounded by persons who would have moral control over
them; relations and friends generally being the worst attendants.